AI in Creative Industries: End of Creativity as We Know It?

On a remote beach in Puerto Rico, Mark Heaps was living a parent's nightmare. 

His son had been stung by a lionfish while swimming, with two venomous spines embedded in his foot. Far from medical help and without Spanish language skills to call emergency services, he turned to an unlikely savior: an AI language model on his phone.

"I described the entire situation and asked it what I should do," Heaps recalls on the Expert Intelligence podcast. "It gave me a series of steps that were spot on and got my son into a stable situation, got him to where he was comfortable for us to move him."

This pivotal moment altered how Heaps, a professional creative turned AI executive who has worked with Apple and Google before becoming Groq’s VP of Brand and Creative, perceives the relationship between humans and artificial intelligence. For him, AI isn't replacing human capability but augmenting it precisely when we need help most.

What Star Wars Teaches Us About AI

Can AI replace creatives?

Heaps views AI not as a replacement for human creativity but as a powerful ally, similar to iconic partnerships in popular culture.

"I often joke that we're moving into an ubiquity of AI and it's kind of like Luke Skywalker in Star Wars having R2-D2 and C-3PO," he explains. "Those are two droids which we could replace with as agents. One of them was a language droid. C-3PO could speak every language of the galaxy. But R2-D2 couldn't, he beeped. He was a logistics operations kind of engineering droid and that helped him with the very technical problems."

“You as a human should still be the hero, but you need these technologies to help you accomplish massive, powerful, great things.”

—Mark Heaps

This is how AI in creative industries should function—as specialized assistants that augment human capabilities rather than replace them. "You as a human should still be the hero," Heaps emphasizes, "but you need these technologies to help you accomplish massive, powerful, great things."

Heaps demonstrated this partnership model with a story about creating a basketball team selection app in seconds. "I literally—there on the sideline [of a basketball game he was playing in]—described into my phone, 'build me an app that can tell you the names of players and the position they play and organize that into groups of five,'" he recounts. "It wrote the app for me in about three seconds, had an interface. I put in people's names and their roles, clicked mix, and immediately I had lineups for teams."

This basketball app example makes AI implementation seem effortless, but the reality of AI in creative industries requires significant organizational change management. As MIT Sloan research highlights, successful integration demands developing effective prompts through study and experimentation, establishing fact-checking protocols, and other steps, substantial investments of time and resources. Organizations that rush AI adoption without addressing these fundamentals often experience what EY research identifies as a decline in enthusiasm for AI integration. 

Creative professionals who achieve the best results are those who treat AI implementation as a deliberate practice, rather than a quick fix, dedicating time to understand the technology's capabilities and limitations before integrating it into established workflows.

How AI in Creative Industries Rewrites Workflows

According to MIT Sloan research, AI is fundamentally changing creative workflows in several key ways:

1. Automation of Routine Production Tasks: AI tools now handle time-consuming tasks such as resizing images, removing backgrounds, generating design variations, and producing simple product videos or social media ads. This allows designers and copywriters to focus on higher-level conceptual work.
2. Rapid Content Generation and Ideation: Generative AI can produce drafts, brainstorm ideas, and generate multiple versions of copy or visuals in minutes. As MIT Sloan notes, "a copywriter can use AI to create several headline options instantly, reducing time spent on initial drafts and overcoming creative blocks."
3. Brand Consistency and Compliance: AI-powered tools can monitor creative assets for brand consistency, flagging off-brand colors, fonts, or messaging. Natural language processing can assess whether copy aligns with the brand's tone, acting as an intelligent proofreader or brand guardian.
4. Workflow Acceleration and Efficiency Gains
   Surveys indicate that generative AI tools can save creative professionals up to 11 hours per week on tasks such as brainstorming, prototyping, and refining content. This efficiency boost allows teams to meet tighter deadlines without sacrificing quality.

"If you have a craft that you love, you like painting, you like drawing, you like taking photos, whatever it is, writing music, the technology isn't stopping you from doing that," Heaps observes. "It does shift maybe how you operate as a business, but this is where you separate artisan from business."

From Hostility to Curiosity: The Evolution of AI in Creative Industries

The creative community's response to AI has undergone a remarkable transformation in a remarkably short time, something Mark Heaps has witnessed firsthand.

"18 months ago, I would walk into a room and talk about AI and people would laugh. They'd go, 'Oh, you mean the app that makes everyone's fingers look like hot dogs? Ha ha ha. You'll never replace us,'" he shares.

That dismissive reaction soon gave way to fear. Heaps recalls having security provided for him at one creative event because of some comments people had made online.

But in just the last six months, he has observed a dramatic shift from fear to curiosity. "I get more people today from the design community, the artist community, messaging me saying, 'Hey, wait, can I do this? Because this would literally let me triple what I produce in a week. That will make me more valuable.'"

[Insert one-track podcast player here]

This evolution mirrors what researchers at MIT Sloan have identified as the three stages of AI adoption in creative fields: resistance, experimentation, and integration. As creative professionals recognize how AI can solve longstanding workflow challenges, attitudes shift from skepticism to enthusiasm.

How AI Targets the “Dirty Laundry” of Creative Work

Creative professionals are discovering that AI in creative industries can address numerous workflow challenges that have plagued teams for decades:

• Communication Gaps and Collaboration Issues: Large creative teams often struggle with fragmented communication, leading to confusion, duplicated work, and prolonged approval processes. Disconnected feedback loops—such as scattered emails, message threads, or physical markups—result in lengthy, disjointed review processes and missed deadlines.
• Version Control and Asset Management: Managing multiple versions of creative assets is a persistent challenge. Without robust systems, teams risk using outdated files, making unnecessary edits, or losing track of the latest approved version, especially problematic when multiple stakeholders are involved.
• Brand Consistency: Ensuring all creative outputs align with brand guidelines becomes increasingly complex when multiple teams and projects run simultaneously. Inconsistencies in colors, fonts, or messaging can dilute brand identity and damage reputation.

"Within every genre of work, there is a subset that is the laundry and the dishes of that role," Heaps explains. "When I first started my career as a creative, I got paid weekly to cut photos out. This was before there were transparencies and all kinds of things in graphic design today. You say 'remove background' in an AI app and it removes it, but I literally would cut out 30 images in a week and pay my rent."

Researchers from the School of Design at Hunan University confirm that creative professionals are increasingly embracing AI to handle repetitive tasks. In their observational study of 20 participants, researchers documented three distinct interaction patterns between designers and AI. The study found that AI can serve as a powerful medium for augmenting human creativity by providing visual stimuli feedback during ideation stages. However, the researchers emphasized that designers must maintain their "agency"—their ability to perform design cognition behaviors, such as monitoring, organizing, planning, clarifying, and reflecting—to collaborate effectively with AI. They observed that designers who began with traditional brainstorming before incorporating AI demonstrated greater agency and achieved better results than those who relied solely on AI from the start. AI integration requires designers to develop specific skills while maintaining critical evaluation of AI outputs.

The Irreplaceable Human Element: Critical Thinking

While AI in creative industries has proven remarkably capable at many tasks, Heaps is adamant that certain quintessentially human abilities remain irreplaceable, particularly critical thinking and inspiration.

"Our greatest value is critical thinking. And AI isn't inspired. AI doesn't walk down a street, hear the sounds and suddenly say, 'I'm going to write a song,'" he notes. "It also doesn't walk down the street and see someone have a problem, you know, maybe with a cane or an object and go, 'I can invent a solution for that.' It has no motivation to do that."

This perspective aligns with research from MIT Horizon, which identifies critical thinking as increasingly valuable in an AI-driven workplace. "As AI systems become more powerful, the human's role shifts toward directing and evaluating AI outputs, which requires robust critical thinking skills," MIT researchers conclude. The researchers also concur with the three-part definition of common sense put forward by cognitive scientist Daniel Willingham:

• “Novel: Not a direct repetition of something you’ve learned before.
• Self-directed: Not just repeating steps you’ve been given.
• Effective: Following patterns that are likely to yield useful conclusions.”

For creative professionals specifically, Heaps suggests that ideation, developing opinions, and collaborative problem-solving will remain distinctly human domains. He describes his approach to incorporating AI in creative sessions: "We actually will talk to AI, to LLMs and say, 'this is our problem, what do you think?' But it can only give us ideas based upon what it's been trained on, which is human ideas." For Mark Heaps, this is a balanced approach that treats AI as one voice in the room rather than the definitive answer.

AI Fatigue and Other Major Concerns within Creative Industries

Despite the potential benefits, many creative professionals harbor legitimate concerns about how AI will affect their careers and livelihoods. Heaps acknowledges these concerns without dismissing them.

"The challenge is how do we figure out helping those people?" he asks, referring to workers whose jobs might be displaced by automation. "And one of Groq's core beliefs is everyone should have access to AI so they can learn it, so they can use it."

“Everyone should have access to AI so they can learn it, so they can use it.”

—Mark Heaps

One challenge deserving of further discussion is AI fatigue, where professionals feel overwhelmed by the rapid evolution of AI tools and capabilities. Recent EY research reveals that half of senior business leaders report a decline in company-wide enthusiasm for AI integration, while 54% feel they are failing as leaders amid AI's rapid growth. This widespread exhaustion threatens to undermine otherwise promising AI initiatives.

To combat this fatigue, organizations must prioritize value over volume in AI implementation, establish clear governance frameworks, invest in education that builds both technical skills and critical thinking capabilities, and create deliberate pauses between major initiatives to allow teams time to adapt. By addressing these issues systematically, companies can sustain AI momentum while preventing burnout.

Harvard Business Review research on AI in the creative industries suggests that as AI becomes more pervasive, the value of certain types of expertise may change. Technical skills that can be automated may decrease in value, while strategic thinking, creative direction, and brand stewardship become more valuable. This counters a frequent concern raised by creative professionals—that expertise will become obsolete.

Heaps draws a compelling parallel to previous technological revolutions: "I remember looking into the data at one point when automation became a big factor in the automotive industry. What's interesting is once upon a time, the automotive industry was completely filled with craft artisans... However, more people today work in automotive using technology than we ever had in history."

This historical perspective suggests that while the nature of work changes with technological advancement, new opportunities often emerge. "What happens is the humans have moved to a different place in their role and they've let the labor part be taken on by the technology," he observes.

The Future of AI in Creative Industries

The impact of AI in creative industries is already visible. Adobe has integrated AI capabilities throughout its Creative Cloud suite, with tools like Generative Fill and Text to Image transforming how designers work. Meanwhile, Canva's Magic Studio has democratized design by making sophisticated AI tools accessible to non-designers.

Major brands are also embracing AI in their creative processes. Coca-Cola created its first AI-generated commercial in 2023, using a combination of generative AI and human creative direction to produce a visually stunning campaign.

As Heaps emphasizes throughout his interview, AI shines when it handles technical execution while humans focus on conceptual excellence; in all these examples, human creative direction remains central to the process. 

He also highlights a significant shift in how people interact with technology—from search-based to conversational interfaces, or what he calls the Language User Interface (LUI). "[My kids] think Googling things is stupid,” he tells Expert Intelligence host Paul Estes. “They absolutely hate it. They think, like, why would I search something that gives me more work to do?"

This shift to conversational AI represents a new paradigm for creative tools. "Scott Belsky, one of the heads over at Adobe, said we're going into the control era," Heaps notes. "And one of the examples of the control era is with any application, how do I actually interact with this thing versus a keyboard, a mouse, you know, even on your phone, you're swiping. And the concept for many folks is we want to have a language user interface."

What the Human+AI Creative Future Means for Enterprise Leaders

As AI in creative industries continues to evolve, enterprise leaders face crucial decisions about how to integrate these technologies while preserving the value of human creativity. Based on Heaps' insights and supporting research, three clear imperatives emerge:

1. Focus on critical thinking and problem-solving skills: As AI handles more technical tasks, human value increasingly lies in identifying problems worth solving, developing novel approaches, and evaluating AI outputs. Enterprise leaders should invest in developing these skills across their creative teams.
2. View AI as a tool of human agency: Rather than replacing creative professionals, leaders should position AI as a powerful ally that helps humans achieve more. The above Star Wars analogy provides a helpful framework: humans remain the heroes, with AI as their specialized, supportive companions.
3. Democratize access to AI tools and education: To navigate this transition successfully, organizations must ensure all team members have opportunities to learn, experiment with, and benefit from AI technologies. This approach reduces fear while maximizing the potential benefits of AI in creative workflows.

The integration of AI in creative industries does not signal the end of human creativity, but rather its evolution and transformation. As Heaps' experiences demonstrate, the most successful applications of AI enhance rather than replace human capabilities, handling the "dirty laundry" of creative work while freeing human minds to focus on what they do best: imagining, connecting, and creating in ways no algorithm can match.

‍